About the Theatre
Our mission is to produce compelling impactful theatre that engages audiences to enrich their lives. Our mission is to create a catalyst for audiences and artists of tomorrow within an intimate, unique, and historical venue through the following:
- By seeking to achieve the highest professional quality theatre through our diverse productions;
- By producing contemporary theatre which engages, inspires, challenges, and entertains our audience;
- By being stewards of the public trust and the resources provided to us by the community;
- By inspiring students and engaging seniors via outreach programs based on the performing arts.
In January of 1853, the trustees of the Cape Island Presbyterian Church purchased a lot on the north side of Lafayette Street, at the corner of what is now Bank Street. Local builder, Peter Hand, designed and built their church. He designed a Georgian-vernacular style building with an oddly graceful, onion-curved, mosque-like belvedere. For the rest of the summer, Cape Islanders and visitors alike thronged the beautiful new church. In the fall of 1853, the Cold Spring trustees sold it to the Methodists.
Where is CMS Located?
What are the prices?
Standard 2020 Season Mainstage Pricing:
Alternate pricing, including discounts, can apply for specific performances. For specific pricing and ticket information for a performance please visit our tickets page.
What accessibility services does CMS offer its patrons?
How do I contact Cape May Stage?
Cape May Stage
31 Perry Street,
Cape May, NJ 08204
Phone: (609) 884-1341
E-Mail: Mitchell Malnati: Administrative Director
Is there a mailing list?
What is your work like?
How big is your theater?
How can I audition?
Cape May Stage holds annual Equity auditions in New York and Cape May. Notices are posted in Backstage and on our website. Submissions are also accepted.
Click here for our auditions for the 2019 season.
Is there parking available at your theatre?
- There is a municipal metered parking lot only a half block south of the playhouse next to Collier’s Liquor store.
- Swain’s Ace Hardware store, located on Jackson Street behind the playhouse has a pre-paid parking lot during the height of the season for $4.00 per vehicle.
- Free parking & free trolley service is available on 921 Lafayette Street at the Cape May Elementary School parking lot during the summer months. The trolley runs every 20 minutes until 11:00PM. The drop off/pick up location of the trolley is at the rotary bandstand across from the playhouse. The phone number to call the trolley driver is (609) 846-4057 to determine his location and timing of your pick up.
I am interested in becoming a volunteer. How can I get involved?
Staff & Board
Producing Artistic Director
Roy Steinberg (Producing Artistic Director) is an actor, director, producer and educator who has worked under almost every contract Equity has to offer. Born in Brooklyn, he attended public schools, then earned a BA magna cum laude from Tufts University with a major in Drama (and a year studying in London) before earning his MFA from Yale School of Drama where he won the Carol Dye Best Actor Award in his class. He made his Broadway debut in the Tony Award-nominated “Wings” playing opposite Tony Award winner Constance Cummings and made his off-Broadway debut playing Lysander in “A Midsummer Night’s Dream” at the Jean Cocteau Repertory Company. He played opposite Academy Award winner Christopher Walken in “Measure for Measure” directed by Academy Award nominee John Madden and played opposite Academy Award winner William Hurt in “The Rimers of Eldritch” at the International Drama Festival in Dundalk, Ireland. Volume 34 of “Theatre World” featured him with a photo and bio . He has played at the Kennedy Center in DC, NY Shakespeare Festival and all over the United States. He directed Farley Grainger and Lynn Cohen in a new play at Circle Repertory and directed Joan Copeland in a new play for the Colleagues Theatre Company in New York. He also directed Kim Hunter, Ann Jackson and Albert Epstein in “The Madwoman of Chaillot” at the Neighborhood Playhouse. He directed at scores of regional theatres and most of the productions at Cape May Stage. He has taught acting and directing at UCLA, NYU, Bera College, Lehman College of the Performing Arts and at Muhlenberg College. He has also been a producer/and or director at CMS and for CBS, NBC and ABC. He has four Emmy nominations for that work. Roy Steinberg was made an honorary member of the Kentucky Colonels along with luminaries like Winston Churchill and Red Skelton – he joined his fellow colonels at the Kentucky Deby.
Director of Development
Mitchell Malnati (Director of Development) graduated from Fordham University in NYC with a B.A. in Theatre. While a love of theatre began through acting, Mitchell found his groove in playwriting. While at Fordham, he was the President of the Playwright’s Guild and had his original plays “The American Family” and “Testament” performed for audiences. His former production company, Mayhaps Productions, produced his original play “Girls: A Two-Act Play about Men” at the Producer’s Club in Times Square for an extended run. In another life, Mitchell was a certified Sommelier and Mixologist. He worked as a Corporate Wine & Beverage Director for many years and traveled through Spain and France visiting vineyards and learning about the winemaking process. One of Mitchell’s proudest accomplishments was starting the Rainbow Alliance, New York’s first gay/straight alliance at a Jesuit college. After becoming a Cape May County resident last year, Mitchell has described coming to Cape May Stage as a perfect moment of serendipity and is so incredibly happy to be involved with the theater once again.
Denise Shutter (Marketing Director) earned a BS in Marketing from Richard Stockton, an A.A. in Fashion Marketing from Art Institute of Philadelphia and an A.A. in Marketing from Camden County Community College. She spent the beginning of her career working for large corporate chains opening new restaurants and training new servers. In 2003 she gave up her career to become a mother and wife to Navy Pilot. She continued to work part time as a consultant to a Party Planning business while raising her three children. As her husband was transferred from different bases she would find ways to continue utilizing her passion for Marketing including starting up a theatre boosters at a local high school and opening her own business. In May of 2015 her family decided to move back to her hometown of Cape May after her husband finished his 14 years in the Navy. She joined the company in 2016 as the Marketing Director and has been excited to see where this journey will lead.
Director of Finance
Joan Flynn (Director of Finance) is a lifelong Cape May County resident and now brings her own artistic talents to Cape May Stage. She is singer and musician who plays over thirteen instruments. Ms. Flynn has been professionally performing in the Tri-State area, and largely in South Jersey, since she was thirteen years old and has co-hosted a weekly Country Music television show. A former EMT, Ms. Flynn comes to us following a fifteen year employment with REIT as a Southern Regional Property Manager. Since 2010 she has served as assistant bookkeeper with a local business services company. Ms. Flynn’s biggest accomplishment and source of pride are her grandchildren. When not at work, you can bet she is with them spending precious time and building lasting memories.
Amy Hadam has been part of the Cape May Stage family since 2016 taking on the role as Production Stage Manager. In the years following Amy has picked up the positions of Education Coordinator and Production Manager as well. Amy graduated from Kean University in 2011 with a BA in Theatre Education where she received her K-12 Teacher Certification for the State of New Jersey. Since graduating, Amy has lead a duel career in stage management and arts education; she joined Actors’ Equity Association as a stage manager in 2012 and has stage managed for many professional New Jersey theatre companies such as Dreamcatcher Repertory Theatre, Surflight Theatre, Speranza Theatre Company, Premiere Stages, and The Theater Project. As an educator, Amy has been a teaching artist for George Street Playhouse, Dreamcatcher Repertory Theatre, and The Theater Project as a choreographer/dance teacher, she was the choreographer for Pequannock Township High School’s musicals from 2015-2017, and has been the dance and theatre instructor for smaller community programs such as Kinetic Kids, Pucci Performing Arts Centre, and Kidsports in The Club at Woodbridge. Amy has been working on further developing Cape May Stage’s Education Program by adding Musical Theatre summer camps for elementary and middle school students and is hopeful to have programs for teenagers launched by the year 2020. She was honored at the New Jersey Theatre Alliance’s 2018 Curtain Call for her contributions to Cape May Stage’s education program along with other education directors throughout the state. Amy is happy to call Cape May Stage home and is looking forward to see what the future brings! FUN FACT: Amy has tattoos of wings on her feet that are a dedication to a dance piece she choreographed in college titled “Break Free”.
Roberta Aungst (Volunteer Coordinator) holds a Masters Degree in Audiology from Penn State University and a Bachelors Degree in Speech Pathology and Audiology from Emerson College. She is a retired clinical audiologist after having practiced in Pennsylvania and New Jersey for more than 50 years. She has served professional state and national associations in multiple committees and board positions including Vice President and President her Pennsylvania association and a Vice President of her national association. She was also a consultant to the Vatican regarding the sainthood of Mother (now Saint) Katherine Drexel.
Roberta has served as the Volunteer Coordinator for Cape May Stage since 2011 and now oversees more than 80 volunteer ushers. She began her tenure with Cape May Stage nine years ago as an usher, later also serving as a scheduler.
Annual orientation sessions are conducted in accordance with the Americans with Disabilities Act and the company liability insurance. Al volunteers are required to attend to review the Policies and Procedures and other information pertinent to the theatre. She communicates frequently with the volunteer staff to apprise them of new developments affecting performance of their duties.
In addition, Roberta supervises a committee of three schedulers, who in turn are tasked with assuring that two ushers are available for each performance. She participates in nearly all special events presented by Cape May Stage and provides administrative support in the office answering phones, selling tickets, and assisting other staff as needed.
Company Manager / Dramaturg
Board of Directors
First Vice President
Second Vice President
Lee Bellarmino, Wendy Collins, Irene Darocha, Kate Hathaway, Mark Kulkowitz, Yogi Kurtz, Karen LoSasso, Marga Matheny, Fran Rixon, Joe Rodgers, Roy Steinberg, and Heather Turner